Owning apartments can be a great investment, but it’s not without its headaches. Think about it – what if a big storm rips your roof off? Or someone slips on your icy steps and sues you? Or, even worse, what if a fire breaks out and you can’t rent out your apartments for months? That’s a lot of potential trouble.
That’s why you need good apartment building insurance companies on your side. They’re like your safety net, catching you when things go wrong. Now, there are tons of apartment building insurance companies in the US, but not all of them are created equal. You want the top apartment building insurance companies, the ones that will actually be there for you when you need them. So, how do you pick the best of the apartment building insurance companies in the US?
Well, we’ve done the hard work for you. We looked at a bunch of apartment building insurance companies and figured out which ones are the real deal. We checked to see if they offer all the right kinds of coverage, if they treat their customers well, if they’re financially strong (you don’t want a company that might go bust when you need them most!), and if they’re reasonably priced.
Basically, we’re going to break down the best of the best, so you can make a smart choice and sleep a little easier at night. Think of this article as your guide to finding the insurance company that’ll have your back, no matter what happens. We want to help you protect your investment, because, let’s face it, owning apartments is a big deal, and you deserve to have the best protection you can get.
What are Apartment Building Insurance Companies?
Apartment building insurance companies specialize in providing tailored policies for landlords and property owners. These policies cover a wide range of risks, including fire, theft, vandalism, liability claims from tenants or visitors, and even loss of rental income due to property damage.
Unlike standard homeowner’s insurance, apartment building insurance is designed specifically for multi-unit properties and often includes additional protections like equipment breakdown coverage and business income protection.
For landlords, having the right insurance policy ensures peace of mind while protecting their financial interests. These companies offer customizable policies to meet the unique needs of apartment building owners, making them indispensable for anyone in the rental property business.
Related: Top 10 Companies Like Velocity REOs in the US | 2025 Updated List
Top 10 Apartment Building Insurance Companies in the US
Here’s a quick list of the top apartment building insurance companies in the US before we look into each one:
1. Travelers Insurance
2. Liberty Mutual
3. Midwest Family Mutual
4. FM Global
5. Chubb Insurance
6. The Hartford
7. State Farm
8. Allstate Insurance
9. Progressive Insurance
10. Berkshire Hathaway (GEICO)
1. Travelers Insurance
Location: Hartford, Connecticut
Overview: Travelers is one of the oldest and most trusted insurance companies in the United States, offering specialized coverage for apartment buildings and other rental properties. It provides comprehensive protection for landlords, ensuring their investments are safeguarded against risks like property damage, liability, and loss of income. Travelers is particularly known for its flexibility, allowing landlords to customize policies to suit their specific needs.
For example, Travelers’ landlord insurance covers various scenarios, including damage caused by fire, theft, vandalism, and even certain natural disasters. It also extends protection to equipment breakdowns and business interruptions. This makes it an ideal choice for landlords who want peace of mind knowing their property and income are secure.
Additionally, Travelers stands out for its excellent customer service and financial stability. It has a strong reputation for handling claims efficiently and providing tailored solutions for complex insurance needs.
Key Features:
- Coverage for property damage, liability claims, business income loss, and equipment breakdown.
- Customizable policies tailored to individual needs.
- Strong financial stability with an A++ rating from AM Best.
Why It’s Recommended: Ideal for landlords who want both standard and custom coverage options with a proven track record of reliability.
2. Liberty Mutual
Location: Boston, Massachusetts
Overview: Liberty Mutual is a well-known and trusted provider of property insurance, offering a variety of options specifically tailored for landlords. The company provides coverage to protect rental properties such as single-family homes, duplexes, triplexes, and even larger residential buildings. Their landlord insurance policies are designed to safeguard the property itself, cover liability issues, and protect against loss of rental income.
The coverage includes protection against damages caused by events like fire, theft, vandalism, and severe weather. It also extends to structures on the property, such as garages or sheds, and covers items owned by the landlord that are used by tenants, like appliances. Additionally, Liberty Mutual offers liability protection to help with legal fees or medical expenses if someone is injured on the property.
One of Liberty Mutual’s standout features is its flexibility. Landlords can customize their policies with options like inflation protection and fair rental value coverage, which compensates for lost rental income if the property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event.
Key Features:
- Protection against property damage, liability claims, inflation adjustments, and fair rental value.
- Discounts for safety features like sprinkler systems and smoke detectors.
- Flexible policies that can be customized based on building size and risk factors.
Why It’s Recommended: Known for competitive pricing and excellent customer satisfaction ratings.
Related: Top 12 Best Seed Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List
3. Midwest Family Mutual
Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota
Overview: Midwest Family Mutual is a well-established insurance company that offers specialized coverage for apartment owners across multiple states in the United States. Founded in 1981, it has built a strong reputation for financial stability and excellent customer service over the years.
The company provides a wide range of insurance options tailored specifically for apartment building owners. These policies are designed to protect landlords from various risks associated with owning and managing rental properties. The coverage typically includes protection against property damage, liability issues, and loss of rental income.
Midwest Family Mutual’s apartment insurance policies are comprehensive, covering scenarios such as fire, theft, vandalism, and certain natural disasters. They also offer coverage for equipment breakdowns and business interruptions, which can be crucial for apartment owners who rely on rental income
Key Features:
- Protection against fire, theft, vandalism, and liability risks.
- Discounts for multiple-unit properties or buildings with safety features.
- High ratings for financial stability and customer service.
Why It’s Recommended: A great choice for landlords looking for affordable yet comprehensive protection.
4. FM Global
Location: Johnston, Rhode Island
Overview: FM Global is a leading insurance company specializing in commercial property coverage, with a unique focus on preventing risks rather than simply responding to them. The company operates on the belief that most property losses can be avoided through careful planning and engineering expertise. To achieve this, FM Global employs over 1,800 engineers and runs one of the largest research operations dedicated to loss prevention in the insurance industry.
Founded in 1835, FM Global has nearly two centuries of experience and serves clients in almost 150 countries. It works primarily with large corporations, including one-third of Fortune 1000 companies, offering tailored insurance solutions for their specific needs. The company’s approach involves evaluating risks at insured locations and recommending improvements to reduce the likelihood of damage or financial loss. This proactive strategy helps businesses safeguard their assets while maintaining operational stability.
Key Features:
- Risk management services to prevent losses before they occur.
- High financial ratings, ensuring timely claim payments.
- Tailored policies for large-scale apartment complexes.
Why It’s Recommended: Perfect for large apartment buildings requiring specialized risk analysis.
5. Chubb Insurance
Location: Warren Township, New Jersey
Overview: Chubb is a global insurance company that offers specialized all-risk coverage designed to meet the complex needs of real estate businesses. This type of insurance provides protection against a wide range of risks, ensuring that property owners and managers are covered for unexpected events, such as natural disasters, structural damage, or liability issues.
What sets Chubb apart is its ability to customize insurance solutions for each client. The company has a dedicated team of industry specialists, including risk engineers and underwriters, who work closely with clients to understand their unique challenges and exposures. This allows Chubb to create tailored policies that address specific risks associated with different types of properties, whether it’s office buildings, apartment complexes, retail spaces, or mixed-use developments.
Key Features:
- Protection against water damage, equipment breakdowns, and even pollutant cleanup costs.
- Includes unique benefits like arson/theft rewards and loss prevention expenses.
Why It’s Recommended: Comprehensive solutions make it ideal for landlords with high-value properties or complex needs.
6. The Hartford
Location: Hartford, Connecticut
Overview: The Hartford is a highly respected insurance company with over 200 years of experience. It provides a wide range of insurance products, including property and casualty insurance, group benefits, and mutual funds. The company is well-known for its strong customer satisfaction ratings and reliable coverage options, making it a trusted choice for individuals and businesses alike.
The Hartford specializes in helping customers protect their most valuable assets and prepare for unexpected events. It offers policies through independent agents and brokers and has a long-standing partnership with AARP to provide auto and home insurance to members aged 50 and older. This partnership has been in place for more than 30 years, offering exclusive benefits and discounts to AARP members.
The company is financially strong, with billions in annual revenue and assets. It is also recognized for its efficient claims handling and commitment to customer service.
Key Features:
- Landlord-specific coverage as an add-on to homeowner policies.
- Covers property damage, lost rental income due to covered events, and liability protection.
- Excellent financial strength ratings from AM Best.
Why It’s Recommended: Best suited for small-scale landlords looking for dependable add-on options.
7. State Farm
Location: Bloomington, Illinois
Overview: State Farm is one of the largest and most trusted insurance companies in the United States, offering landlord insurance policies that are available nationwide. These policies are designed to provide comprehensive protection for rental property owners, covering a wide range of risks that landlords may face.
State Farm’s landlord insurance typically includes coverage for the building itself, protecting it against damage caused by events like fire, storms, or vandalism. It also offers liability coverage, which helps if someone is injured on the property or if the landlord is held legally responsible for damages. Additionally, landlords can include loss of rental income coverage, which compensates them if their property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event.
What makes State Farm stand out is its ability to customize policies based on the specific needs of landlords. Whether you own a single-family rental home, a duplex, or a larger apartment complex, State Farm provides flexible options to suit your property type.
Key Features:
- Competitive premiums with customizable options based on property size and location.
- Strong financial backing ensures timely claim payouts during disasters.
Why It’s Recommended: Trusted by millions due to its scale and reliability.
Related: Top 11 Insurance Companies Hiring Remote Workers in the USA
8. Allstate Insurance
Location: Northbrook, Illinois
Overview: Allstate offers landlord insurance policies designed to protect property owners who rent out homes, apartments, or other residential spaces. These policies provide essential coverage to safeguard landlords from financial losses and unexpected situations. One key feature is liability coverage, which helps cover medical expenses or legal costs if someone is injured on the rental property and the landlord is found responsible. For example, if a tenant falls due to broken stairs, the liability coverage can assist with the resulting expenses.
Another important aspect of Allstate’s landlord insurance is reimbursed living expenses, also known as fair rental income coverage. This ensures landlords receive compensation for lost rental income if the property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event, such as fire or water damage. This coverage can last for up to 12 months while repairs are being made.
In addition to these protections, Allstate covers the physical structure of the rental property, including the dwelling itself and other structures like detached garages or sheds.
Key Features:
- Coverage against theft, fire damage, vandalism, and plumbing-related water damage.
- Add-ons available for vacant units or properties under construction.
- Fair rental income protection included as standard.
Why It’s Recommended: Great choice for landlords seeking bundled policy options.
9. Progressive Insurance
Location: Mayfield Village, Ohio
Overview: Progressive is a well-known insurance company recognized for its innovative approach to landlord insurance. It offers flexible policy options that cater to the diverse needs of landlords, making it easier for property owners to find coverage that suits their specific requirements. Progressive’s policies are designed to protect rental properties from various risks, including damage caused by fire, theft, or vandalism. They also provide liability coverage, which helps landlords handle legal or medical expenses if someone is injured on their property.
One of the standout features of Progressive is its customizable coverage. Landlords can adjust their policies to include additional protections, such as compensation for lost rental income if the property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event. This flexibility ensures landlords get the exact level of protection they need without paying for unnecessary extras.
Key Features:
- Competitive pricing with multi-policy discounts available (e.g., bundling auto and landlord insurance).
- Coverage tailored to small or mid-sized apartment buildings.
Why It’s Recommended: Ideal for cost-conscious landlords who still want reliable coverage.
10. Berkshire Hathaway (GEICO)
Location: Omaha, Nebraska (Parent Company)
Overview: GEICO offers affordable landlord insurance policies backed by the financial strength of Berkshire Hathaway, one of the most stable companies globally. These policies are designed to protect landlords and their rental properties without sacrificing quality. GEICO’s landlord insurance covers various risks, including property damage caused by events like fire, storms, or vandalism. It also provides liability coverage to help landlords manage legal or medical expenses if someone is injured on their property.
Additionally, GEICO offers coverage for lost rental income in cases where the property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event. Landlords can also choose extra protections, such as coverage for vandalism, stolen items, or additional construction costs to meet building codes after damage.
GEICO’s policies are customizable, allowing landlords to tailor their coverage to match the specific needs of their rental properties.
Key Features:
- Comprehensive landlord insurance covering property damage and liability risks at competitive rates.
- Streamlined claims process backed by strong financial resources.
Why It’s Recommended: A reliable option for landlords seeking value-driven policies with excellent claims handling.
Related: Top 10 Telecom Audit Companies in the USA in 2025
Conclusion
Choosing the right apartment building insurance company is crucial to protecting your investment from unforeseen risks like natural disasters or tenant-related liabilities.
Each of these top companies offers unique strengths, whether it’s Travelers’ customizable policies or Chubb’s comprehensive all-risk solutions, making them stand out as leaders in the industry.
When selecting an insurer from this list of top apartment building insurance companies in the US for 2025, consider your specific needs like building size, location risks (e.g., flood-prone areas), and budget constraints. Comparing quotes from multiple providers will help you find the best fit while ensuring your investment remains secure.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What does apartment building insurance typically cover?
Apartment building insurance generally covers property damage (e.g., from fires or storms), liability claims (e.g., tenant injuries), loss of rental income due to covered events, equipment breakdowns (e.g., HVAC systems), and sometimes flood or earthquake damages if added as endorsements.
2. How much does apartment building insurance cost?
Costs vary depending on factors like location, building size/age, number of units, safety features installed (e.g., sprinkler systems), and chosen coverage limits. On average, premiums range between $500 to $2,000 per year per unit.
3. Do I need separate flood or earthquake insurance?
Standard apartment building insurance typically excludes flood or earthquake damages unless explicitly added as endorsements. If your property is in a high-risk area (e.g., flood zones), consider purchasing additional coverage.
4. How do I choose the best insurer?
Look at factors like financial stability (AM Best ratings), customer reviews (claims handling experience), available discounts (e.g., safety features), and customizable policy options that suit your specific needs as a landlord. Comparing quotes from multiple providers can also help you find the best fit for your needs.
