Top 10 Worst Car Insurance Companies in the US

Selecting the worst car insurance companies could leave you stranded in challenging situations. On the other hand, choosing the right auto insurance company is crucial, as the right provider will be there when you need them most, especially in the aftermath of an accident.

With thousands of car insurance providers to choose from, it can be overwhelming to determine which ones offer dependable service and which ones should be avoided.

These companies have consistently received negative feedback from customers, particularly regarding slow claims processing, poor customer service, and high premiums. In many cases, these insurers fail to meet basic expectations, causing frustration for policyholders during critical moments.

By highlighting the worst car insurance companies, we aim to guide consumers toward better choices. Understanding which companies have the most complaints and least satisfaction can help you avoid potential headaches.

Whether you’re shopping for your first policy or considering a switch, this list can serve as a helpful resource in making a well-informed decision about your car insurance provider.

To help you navigate this decision, we’ve examined expert research, customer reviews, complaint data, and other relevant sources to compile a list of the top 10 worst car insurance companies in 2025.

How to Choose a Reliable Car Insurer

The best way to avoid getting stuck with the worst car insurance companies is to approach your decision-making process with caution and diligence. Taking the time to carefully evaluate your options now can save you from future frustration, especially when you need your insurance coverage the most. Here’s how you can effectively navigate the car insurance landscape:

1. Compare Multiple Quotes

While it might be tempting to choose the cheapest initial rate, it’s essential to compare quotes from multiple insurance providers. Different insurers offer varying coverage options, discounts, and rates. By obtaining quotes from a variety of companies, you can ensure you’re getting the best value for your area. Keep in mind that the lowest rate may not always offer the best coverage, so balance price with quality of service.

2. Research Ratings and Reviews

Customer reviews provide valuable insight into how an insurer handles claims, customer service, and overall satisfaction. Researching ratings and reviews from trusted sources such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB), J.D. Power, and Consumer Reports can offer an unbiased perspective of a company’s track record. Pay attention to recurring complaints, such as slow claims processing or poor communication, which are common red flags.

3. Verify Complaint Ratios

Every insurer will have some level of complaints, but comparing the ratio of complaints to other top insurers in your area is a key indicator of how well a company is performing. Websites like the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) allow consumers to view complaint ratios, helping you gauge whether a company is more prone to receiving grievances than its competitors. The fewer the complaints, the more likely it is that the insurer is doing right by its customers.

4. Look for Financial Stability Ratings

Before committing to an insurance provider, it’s critical to check their financial stability. A company’s financial health ensures that it can pay claims and stay operational in the long term, especially in times of widespread damage, such as after natural disasters. Services like AM Best, Moody’s, and Standard & Poor’s provide financial strength ratings that can help you assess whether the insurer is solvent and reliable.

5. Work with an Independent Agent

Independent agents represent multiple insurance providers and can offer impartial advice. They can explain the nuances of different policies, coverage options, and help you understand which insurer offers the best fit for your needs. Unlike captive agents who work for a single company, independent agents have the flexibility to shop around and tailor their recommendations based on your specific requirements.

6. Take Your Time

Lastly, it’s essential to avoid rushing into a decision. Take your time to thoroughly compare insurers and ensure that you are comfortable with both the price and the coverage. By reviewing all aspects of a policy—including deductibles, exclusions, and customer support—you can feel confident that you are making an informed choice. Rushing into a policy without considering all factors might lead to unwanted surprises, especially if you need to file a claim.

1. Progressive Insurance

Progressive is one of the largest auto insurers in the U.S., but it consistently ranks poorly in customer satisfaction surveys.

Despite offering competitive prices, the company is often criticized for poor claims handling and low customer service ratings.

Many customers report delays in claim settlements, with issues such as slow response times and difficulty getting assistance. This has led to frustration, especially during stressful situations.

While Progressive may offer affordable premiums, its lack of effective support and timely claims resolution can leave policyholders feeling dissatisfied and unsupported when they need it most.

visit company

2. Allstate

Allstate has gained a reputation for high premiums and subpar customer service. Many customers report long wait times for claims and difficulty contacting representatives.

The claims process is often slow, with several customers expressing dissatisfaction with the payout amounts.

Additionally, Allstate’s discounts can be misleading, leaving policyholders feeling misinformed or disappointed.

These issues have led to a decline in customer satisfaction, with many consumers seeking better service and more transparency from their insurance provider.

Despite being a well-known brand, Allstate’s high costs and poor customer support have made it less favorable for many drivers.

visit company

3. Geico

Geico is another major insurer that frequently receives negative feedback, particularly regarding customer service.

While the company is known for offering competitive rates, many customers report poor claims handling. Common complaints include long claim settlement times, disputes over claim amounts, and unresponsive customer support.

These issues can create frustration for policyholders, especially during stressful situations. Despite its affordable premiums, the lack of timely communication and efficient claims processing has led many to seek alternatives.

While Geico offers cost-effective coverage, its customer service shortcomings can significantly affect the overall customer experience.

visit company

4. State Farm

Despite being one of the largest and most recognizable insurers in the U.S., State Farm is often criticized for its high premiums, particularly for drivers with less-than-perfect records.

Many customers report a frustrating claims process, poor communication, and unsatisfactory payout amounts.

Additionally, State Farm’s customer service is frequently described as unresponsive or indifferent, leaving policyholders feeling neglected.

These issues, combined with the high costs, have contributed to State Farm’s reputation as one of the worst insurance companies for those seeking value and efficient service.

As a result, many customers feel that the service does not match the premium rates.

visit company

5. Farmers Insurance

Farmers Insurance has faced criticism for its high premiums, particularly for drivers with little or no previous claims history.

While the company offers a range of coverage options, its claims process is often slow, with many customers reporting delays in resolution.

Additionally, some policyholders have expressed dissatisfaction with being underpaid on claims. Poor communication and lack of transparency during the claims process have been common complaints, leading to frustration among customers.

These issues, combined with the high costs, have contributed to a negative reputation for Farmers Insurance in terms of both service and value.

visit company

6. Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual has faced significant criticism for its pricing and poor customer service. Many customers report that their premiums are high, particularly for basic coverage, making it less affordable compared to other insurers.

The claims process is often described as slow, with delays in communication and unsatisfactory payouts.

Many policyholders feel that Liberty Mutual fails to prioritize their needs, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction.

These issues have contributed to the company’s negative reputation, with numerous consumers seeking more responsive and cost-effective options for their auto insurance needs.

visit company

7. USAA

While USAA is highly regarded for providing excellent service to military members and their families, it has received some criticism from non-military customers.

Many report that its service and claims process are less responsive compared to other insurers.

Additionally, the company’s website and mobile app are often described as difficult to navigate, frustrating users.

USAA’s rates may also be higher for drivers with poor credit histories or less-than-perfect driving records, which can make it less appealing for certain customers.

Despite its strong reputation within the military community, some consumers feel the company’s service falls short for others.

visit company

8. Nationwide

Nationwide is frequently criticized for high rates and poor customer service. Many customers report slow claims processing, with long wait times and a lack of communication throughout the claims process.

Additionally, the company’s discounts are often difficult to access and may not deliver the savings that customers anticipate.

This has led to dissatisfaction among policyholders who feel they are not receiving value for their money.

The combination of high costs, slow service, and unfulfilled discount promises contributes to a negative perception of Nationwide among many consumers.

visit company

9. MetLife

MetLife offers a wide range of coverage options, but its customer service has been consistently criticized. Many customers report delayed claim processing, unhelpful representatives, and low settlement offers, leading to dissatisfaction.

Additionally, MetLife’s premiums are often high, making it less appealing for those seeking affordable coverage.

The company’s lack of transparency in billing and pricing structures further frustrates policyholders, leaving them feeling misled.

Despite the variety of coverage available, these service and pricing issues have contributed to MetLife’s negative reputation among consumers, particularly for those seeking both value and reliable service.

visit company

10. The Hartford

While The Hartford is a popular choice for some drivers, it has faced significant negative feedback, particularly regarding its claims process.

Customers frequently complain about slow response times, lack of follow-up, and low payout amounts.

Although the company offers competitively priced policies, the overall customer experience is often disappointing, especially when it comes to claims handling.

Many customers report poor communication throughout the process, which adds to their frustration.

Despite offering affordable coverage, these issues with claims and service contribute to The Hartford’s reputation as a less reliable insurer for those in need of timely and effective support.

visit company

FAQs

What makes a car insurance company one of the worst?

A car insurance company can be considered one of the worst if it consistently provides poor customer service, has a slow and inefficient claims process, offers low payouts, has high premiums for limited coverage, or receives numerous customer complaints. Companies with a lack of transparency in pricing or communication are often rated poorly.

How can I avoid the worst car insurance companies?

To avoid the worst car insurance companies, it’s important to compare quotes from multiple providers, read customer reviews, check the company’s claims handling process, and verify their financial stability. It’s also helpful to review their customer satisfaction ratings and complaints record.

Are cheaper car insurance companies always the worst?

Not necessarily. While some low-cost providers may offer poor service, others may provide value through competitive rates and good customer care. The key is to balance price with customer service and claims efficiency. Always do your research before committing to a cheap policy.

What are the signs of a bad car insurance company?

Signs of a bad car insurance company include delayed claims processing, unresponsive customer service, frequent billing issues, misleading discounts, and negative reviews from many customers. A company with consistent complaints about slow response times or poor claims outcomes should be avoided.

Can I switch car insurance companies if I’m unhappy with my current provider?

Yes, you can switch car insurance companies at any time. If you’re unhappy with your current provider’s service or rates, it’s advisable to compare other options, select a better insurer, and cancel your current policy. Make sure to check for any penalties or fees related to cancellation before making the switch.

Conclusion

While there are many car insurance providers to choose from, not all offer the same level of service.

The worst car insurance companies listed above are frequently mentioned in customer complaints for issues ranging from high premiums and slow claims processing to poor customer service.

Before choosing an insurer, it’s crucial to carefully research customer reviews, claim handling processes, and overall satisfaction.

Always consider factors such as customer support, pricing, and claims efficiency to ensure you’re getting the best possible coverage for your needs.

Top 10 Worst Car Insurance Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List