Insurance is one of the most critical tools for financial security, offering protection against unexpected events that could otherwise derail personal or business finances. Imagine you’re driving to work, and suddenly, your car breaks down, or you’re at home when a storm hits, causing damage to your roof.
These unexpected events can be really stressful and expensive to repair. That’s when you need insurance. It’s like having a safety net to protect you from financial shocks. Even if you’re worried about your health, car, home, or business, the right insurance policy can give you peace of mind and keep your finances stable.
Pittsburgh is a great example of a city that’s full of life and diversity. It has a strong economy and a mix of people from all walks of life. Because of this, there are many insurance companies in Pittsburgh that offer customized plans to fit different needs. Some people might need health insurance, while others might want coverage for their business or home.
This article is going to show you the top insurance companies in Pittsburgh in 2025. We’ve picked these companies based on how happy their customers are, how affordable their plans are, the types of coverage they offer, and how financially stable they are.
Table of Contents
Criteria for Selection
The following criteria were used to evaluate and rank the top 10 insurance companies in Pittsburgh:
- Customer Satisfaction: Ratings from platforms like J.D. Power and customer reviews.
- Financial Strength: Evaluations from agencies such as A.M. Best.
- Product Variety and Affordability: The range of services offered and their cost-effectiveness.
- Accessibility: Availability of online tools, local offices, and customer support.
- Specialized Services: Unique offerings tailored to specific demographics or industries.
Related: 12 Best Entertainment Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List
Top 10 Insurance Companies in Pittsburgh
Here is an overview of the top insurance companies in Pittsburgh in 2025. These companies have been selected based on their reputation, services offered, and ability to meet diverse insurance needs.
1. AIG
AIG, short for American International Group, is one of the biggest names in the insurance world. Founded way back in 1919, this company has grown into a global powerhouse with operations in nearly 190 countries. While its headquarters are in New York City, AIG has a strong presence in Pittsburgh, making it a go-to choice for both individuals and businesses in the area.
What makes AIG stand out is the wide range of insurance products it offers. Whether you need coverage for your car, health, life, or even your business, AIG has you covered. They’re especially known for their innovative risk management solutions, which help clients prepare for and handle unexpected challenges.
From small businesses to massive corporations, AIG tailors its policies to fit specific needs. This flexibility is one reason why so many companies in industries like healthcare, manufacturing, and technology trust AIG.
Another thing that sets AIG apart is its focus on customer satisfaction. They’ve earned a reputation for being responsive when it comes to claims processing, which is a big deal for anyone who’s ever had to file an insurance claim. On top of that, their financial strength means clients can rely on them to deliver on their promises.
2. Henderson Brothers Inc.
Henderson Brothers Inc. is a name that’s deeply rooted in Pittsburgh’s history, having been around since 1893. The company started as a steamboat line, navigating the Ohio River and managing the risks of river travel for its clients.
Over time, it transitioned into insurance, employee benefits, and retirement solutions, becoming one of the most trusted names in the industry. Today, Henderson Brothers operates out of its headquarters at 920 Fort Duquesne Boulevard in Pittsburgh and serves thousands of clients locally and internationally.
What makes Henderson Brothers stand out is its commitment to providing personalized service. They don’t just sell insurance, they take the time to understand their clients’ needs and design solutions that fit perfectly. Whether it’s helping businesses with employee benefits or offering personal property and casualty insurance, Henderson Brothers has built a reputation for going above and beyond. Their expertise spans industries like healthcare, education, construction, and manufacturing, making them a versatile choice for businesses of all sizes.
The company also excels in risk management consulting, helping clients navigate complex challenges while protecting their assets. Their long-standing relationships with top insurance carriers ensure that customers get access to the best products on the market. This dedication to quality and customer satisfaction has earned them glowing reviews over the years.
Related: Top 11 Survey Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List
3. Koop Technologies
Koop Technologies is a young and exciting insurance company based in Pittsburgh, founded in 2020. What makes Koop so unique is its focus on the future, specifically on providing insurance solutions for emerging technologies like autonomous vehicles, robotics, and drones.
As the world moves toward automation, traditional insurance policies often fall short in addressing the risks associated with these advanced technologies. Koop steps in to fill that gap, offering tailored coverage for tech-driven industries that rely on cutting-edge machines rather than human operators.
The company’s headquarters at Nova Place in Pittsburgh is no coincidence. Pittsburgh has become a hub for robotics and autonomous vehicle development, earning it the nickname “RoboBurgh.” Koop’s founders recognized this as the perfect environment to grow their business, surrounded by innovation and some of the brightest minds in technology. The team behind Koop includes experts with diverse backgrounds in technology, insurance, and business, all of whom share a vision of reshaping how insurance works for the autonomy industry.
One of Koop’s standout features is its use of data. Unlike traditional insurers, Koop relies on data-sharing platforms to assess risks and create customized policies for its clients. This approach allows them to offer more accurate coverage and better rates for businesses operating in industries like autonomous transportation, industrial robotics, agriculture, and even drone delivery. For example, they’ve developed specialized products like “Robotics Errors & Omissions Insurance,” which protects companies from costly lawsuits tied to machine-related incidents.
4. Highmark Blue Shield
Highmark Blue Shield is a major player in the health insurance industry, especially in Pittsburgh, where its headquarters are located. Since its founding in 1977, Highmark has grown into one of the largest Blue Cross Blue Shield affiliates in the country, serving millions of members across Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, and parts of New York. It’s known for providing comprehensive health insurance solutions that cater to individuals, families, and businesses.
What sets Highmark apart is its extensive network coverage and wide variety of plans. Whether you’re looking for individual health insurance or employer-sponsored benefits, Highmark has options to suit different needs.
For seniors, its Medicare Advantage plans are particularly popular and have earned high ratings for quality and affordability. In fact, some of its plans have consistently received top scores from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), which speaks volumes about their reliability and customer satisfaction.
Highmark doesn’t just focus on offering coverage, it’s deeply committed to making healthcare more accessible and understandable for everyone. The company works hard to simplify the insurance process, ensuring that customers can easily find the right plan and access care when they need it. This dedication to affordability and accessibility has made Highmark a trusted name in Pittsburgh and beyond.
Related: 15 Best Car Transport Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List
5. HUB International
HUB International is a well-established insurance company with its headquarters in Chicago, but it also has a strong presence in Pittsburgh through its regional offices. Founded in 1998, HUB has grown into one of the largest insurance brokers globally, offering a broad spectrum of insurance products for both personal and commercial needs.
What sets HUB apart is its extensive range of services. Whether you’re looking for insurance to protect your home, car, or business, HUB has a solution tailored to fit your needs. They’re particularly renowned for their expertise in employee benefits programs, helping businesses create comprehensive packages that attract and retain top talent. This includes everything from health insurance to retirement plans, all designed to support the well-being of employees.
One of HUB’s specializations is crafting customized insurance policies for niche markets. For instance, they have specialized products for industries like agriculture and real estate. These sectors often have unique risks that standard insurance policies might not cover adequately.
HUB’s team works closely with clients to understand these specific challenges and develop policies that address them effectively. This personalized approach has earned HUB a reputation for being responsive to the diverse needs of its clients.
6. Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency
Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency, founded in 1985, is a well-respected name in Pittsburgh’s insurance scene, known for providing a wide range of insurance products to individuals, families, and businesses. As a leading provider of ERIE Insurance, they have established themselves as a trusted partner in the community, with multiple locations across the region, including Squirrel Hill, Mt. Lebanon, McMurray, and Wexford.
What sets Preston & Grafton apart is their commitment to personalized service. They take the time to understand each client’s unique needs and tailor insurance policies accordingly. Whether it’s home, auto, life, or commercial business insurance, they offer customized solutions that fit each client’s specific situation. This approach has helped them build strong relationships with their customers, many of whom appreciate the agency’s ability to simplify complex insurance decisions.
As an independent agency, Preston & Grafton has the flexibility to work with multiple insurance carriers, ensuring they can find the best rates and coverage options for their clients.
Their team is dedicated to providing exceptional customer service, recognizing that life is full of stresses and uncertainties. They strive to be a trusted advisor, not just an insurance provider, helping clients navigate changes in their lives and insurance needs over time.
Related: Top 10 Worst Car Insurance Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List
7. HM Insurance Group
HM Insurance Group is a company based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and it has been around since the mid-1980s. They specialize in providing stop-loss insurance products, which are crucial for employers who manage their own health plans. This type of insurance acts as a safety net, protecting employers from unexpected medical expenses that can quickly add up.
What HM Insurance Group does best is helping self-funded employers manage their healthcare costs effectively. Self-funded employers are those who pay for their employees’ healthcare expenses directly rather than relying on traditional insurance plans.
HM works closely with these employers to ensure they have the right protection in place. By offering reinsurance solutions, HM helps employers limit their financial exposure to large medical claims, which can be a significant burden on any business.
HM’s approach is highly personalized, focusing on understanding the unique needs of each employer. They work to tailor their insurance products to fit specific business goals and budgets, ensuring that employers get the best possible coverage without breaking the bank. This personalized service has earned HM a reputation for being responsive and supportive, making them a trusted partner for businesses looking to manage healthcare costs efficiently.
8. AAA East Central
AAA East Central has been a trusted name in Pittsburgh for decades, offering much more than just insurance. While it’s best known for its auto insurance, AAA East Central also provides home and life insurance, along with a range of other services like travel planning and emergency roadside assistance. Its headquarters is located in the historic Motor Square Garden building in the East Liberty neighborhood of Pittsburgh, a landmark that adds to its local charm and presence.
This branch of AAA has roots going back to the early 1900s, making it one of the oldest names in the region when it comes to serving drivers and travelers. Over time, AAA East Central has built a reputation for being reliable and customer-focused.
One of its standout features is its membership benefits, which include 24/7 roadside assistance, a lifesaver for anyone who’s ever dealt with a flat tire or a dead battery on the road. Members also get access to discounts on travel, hotels, and attractions, making it much more than just an insurance provider.
AAA East Central is especially popular among drivers because it bundles auto services with insurance coverage. This means you’re not only protected financially if something happens to your car but also have access to practical help when you need it most. Whether you’re stranded on the side of the road or planning a cross-country trip, AAA has tools and services to make life easier.
The company’s headquarters at Motor Square Garden is itself a piece of Pittsburgh history. Originally built as a market house in 1900, the building has served many purposes over the years before becoming AAA’s home in 1988. Its distinctive dome and architectural design make it one of the city’s iconic landmarks.
Related: Top 10 Volumetric Building Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List
9. Gateway Financial Group
Gateway Financial Group is a well-established insurance advisory firm headquartered in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, at 4 PPG Place. Founded in 1982, the company has built a strong reputation for providing tailored financial and insurance solutions to meet the unique needs of individuals and businesses.
While it specializes in life insurance policies with investment components, Gateway also focuses heavily on retirement planning, making it a trusted partner for those looking to secure their financial future.
What makes Gateway Financial stand out is its consultative approach. The team doesn’t just sell insurance, they work closely with clients to understand their goals and challenges. For individuals, Gateway helps create plans that provide financial security for families while preserving wealth for future generations. For businesses, they offer solutions like executive benefits and buy-sell agreements that ensure stability and continuity.
Gateway Financial has a diverse client base that includes ultra-high-net-worth individuals, professional sports franchises, Fortune 500 companies, and national law firms. This range shows their ability to adapt and provide specialized services for varying needs. Their expertise isn’t limited to insurance alone; they also integrate wealth management strategies to help clients maximize returns on investments intended for heirs or long-term financial goals.
10. Hurley Insurance Brokers
Hurley Insurance Brokers is a well-known independent insurance agency based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and has been serving clients across the state for decades. While the exact year of its founding varies in records, the company has firmly established itself as a trusted provider of both personal and commercial insurance policies. What makes Hurley Insurance Brokers stand out is its independence, which means they aren’t tied to any single insurance carrier. Instead, they work with multiple providers to find the best rates and coverage options for their clients.
The agency is led by Brennan Hurley, who has been at the helm since 2009. Under his leadership, Hurley Insurance Brokers has built a reputation for delivering personalized service and paying close attention to detail. They take the time to understand what each client truly needs and then recommend tailored solutions that fit those requirements. Whether it’s a homeowner looking for property insurance or a business owner needing a comprehensive commercial package, Hurley Insurance Brokers ensures that every policy is designed with the client’s best interests in mind.
One of their key strengths is their ability to offer competitive rates by comparing options from different carriers. This flexibility allows them to cater to a wide range of clients, from individuals seeking basic coverage to businesses with more complex insurance needs. Their services extend across various types of insurance, including home, auto, business, and even specialty policies.
Despite not being accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Hurley Insurance Brokers holds an impressive A+ rating, which reflects their commitment to quality service and customer satisfaction. Their office is located at 800 Old Pond Road in Bridgeville, PA, making them easily accessible to clients in Pittsburgh and surrounding areas.
Related: Top 10 Commercial Real Estate Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List
Tabular Comparison of the Top Insurance Companies
| Company Name | Year Founded | Key Services | Specialization |
| AIG | 1919 | Life, Auto, Health | Large corporations |
| Henderson Brothers Inc. | 1893 | Employee Benefits | Local businesses |
| Koop Technologies | Recent | Tech Insurance | Emerging technologies |
| Highmark Blue Shield | 1977 | Health Insurance | Individual & family healthcare |
| HUB International | 1998 | Personal & Commercial Insurance | Niche markets |
| Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency | 1985 | Home, Auto, Life, Commercial Business Insurance | Personalized ERIE Insurance products |
| HM Insurance Group | Mid-1980s | Stop-Loss Insurance | Self-funded employers |
| AAA East Central | Early 1900s | Auto & Home Insurance | Drivers |
| Gateway Financial Group | Late1990s | Life & Retirement Planning | Financial planning |
| Hurley Insurance Brokers | Mid-century | Personal & Commercial Policies | Personalized service |
Tips for Choosing the Right Insurance Company
Selecting the right insurer is crucial to ensuring you get the best coverage at an affordable price. Here are some tips:
- Assess your specific needs based on your life stage and budget (e.g., health vs. auto insurance).
- Compare quotes from multiple providers using online tools or brokers.
- Check customer reviews and complaint records through trusted platforms like J.D. Power or BBB ratings.
- Consider bundling policies (e.g., home + auto) to save money.
Related: Top 10 Mold Testing Companies in the US | 2025 Updated List
Conclusion
Pittsburgh is home to some of the most reliable insurance companies in the country. From large multinational corporations like AIG to local favorites such as Henderson Brothers Inc., these providers offer a wide range of services tailored to meet diverse needs.
Choosing the right insurer can make all the difference in securing your financial future, so take time to evaluate your options carefully.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the most popular types of insurance in Pittsburgh?
Health, auto, home, and life insurance are among the most sought-after types in the city.
2. How can I find affordable insurance in Pittsburgh?
Compare quotes online or consult independent brokers who work with multiple carriers.
3. Is it better to choose a local or national insurer?
Both have advantages, local insurers often provide personalized service while national companies offer broader networks.
4. Can I bundle different types of insurance?
Yes! Bundling policies (e.g., home + auto) often results in discounts from many providers.
References
- builtin.com– Top Pittsburgh, PA Insurance Companies
- m.yelp.com– Top 10 Best Insurance Near Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania – With Real Reviews
